Friday, February 26, 2010

Debating a Brick Wall

Chait at TNR characterizes the GOP side of Health Care debate perfectly:
The thing is, that kind of debunked objection is the deepest and most detailed reply I've seen from the GOP all day. The best ones have specific but misinformed views. The worst ones are like Boehner. Now, I'm sure a great many Democrats in Congress also have a pretty sketchy understanding of the issue. But this summit is showing the sheer impossibility of trying to find intellectual common ground. John Podhoretz calls Obama "startlingly condescending at moments." How can that be avoided when you're trying to have a high-level discussion with people who reply either on debunked claims at best and talk radio-level slogans at worst?
Actually, this pretty much describes the current level of GOP participation in most other debates, too. And remember, the party of "no government" always wins a stalemate.

No comments: